How is the issue of “language” reflected in "Wide Sargasso Sea"? Is it a block or a border between two groups, or a means of communication between different cultures?
Firstly, it is for sure that language in this novel is not a simple medium to transfer the emotions, desires and opinions as a whole. Rather, it symbolizes the social strata in which the character is; that is we, as readers, understand that this character belongs to this category because he or she speaks in a different dialect whether for worse or for better. For instance, we immediately identify Christophine with her patois dialect as we do the same in the case of Rochester although he is unnamed in the novel.
We see the strong force of language throughout the novel; because it is as if having a mirror function which reflects the effects of language on people through bias, lies and gossips. For instance, let us think of the dialogues between Antoinette and her husband and Amelia or Christophine. There is not any problem in the communication between the partners; but Rochester remarks his detest for their dialects. He says that “Christophine’s coffee is delicious but her language is horrible; she is a very worthy person no doubt, but I can’t say I like her her language.” In another passage, he directly thinks that he does not trust to these people as Antoinette does. Besides their outlooks, he is under the strong impression of language.
As we regard the label of “mad” which is given to the mother of Antoinette, we come to the same conclusion that “language” is the utmost importance which may have result in disastrous effects on every single person. Anette is sent away from her daughter Antoinette and is not allowed to see either her neighbours or her family. Christophine says that she may not be mad; but after such a treatment, she gives up struggling and be a “mad” which is a role cut by other people through the language.
We also see different versions of the “truth” of Antoinette’s family experiences. Later in the story, Daniel writes a letter to Rochester informing him of the “real” aim of the family and his wife. However, when we listen to Antoniette’s version, we see that it sharply contrasts with the previous one. In this point, language does not serve as a facilitative medium; rather, it is presented as a “power” which causes discrepancies and scandals to block the communication between peoples.
In another part, Rochester calls Antoniette as “Bertha”, because he is fond of the name. Antoniette sees it as an effort to “make her into another person”. We clearly know that this can not be materialized in fact. However, remembering the “mad” label cut for her mother Anette, she gradually becomes that mad woman. Therefore, there is the definite effect of the language which is used in a community to “shape” its inhabitants. Language, as we see in the case of Antoinette and her mother throughout the novel, is the most effective way in forming the direction of peoples' life styles.
my dear. you have written wonderfully. ı liked the way you gave examples from the novel and you really explained the important parts, especially the power of language:D
YanıtlaSilDear Hande,
YanıtlaSilçok güzel;-) I really enjoyed reading your essay.
I just noticed that I used the same quote (in the third paragraph) in my essay, because I also think it is one of the most important passages about language in the novel.
I just did not understand the connection between madness and language, which you made in your fourth paragraph.
:) Thank you very much Wibke.
YanıtlaSilI will try to explain it once again for you. What I try to say is that as far as I remember from the sociology class last year, language has such a power that it can affect people's behaviors and their pyschological states. In this point, I give the example of Anette: because she may not be "mad" originally. However; as other people continually sees her as a "mad woman", Anette becomes one, obeying the rules and the categories drawn by the society.
Let's think of another word: "inferior" for example. If an individual is seen by others as inferior to themselves, s/he "becomes" feeling inferior to others as if it is real. We know that it is false. There should never be such a discrimination. But, language is so important that if you categorize people within the frames of language, you should not forget its positive or negative impacts upon every single entity.
That's it! :)
Hello untiring bloggers of 365,
YanıtlaSilI enjoyed both Hande's writing and the discussion that Wiebke launched. Indeed, I also got a bit puzzled about that point while reading the print version of your post, Hande. But then I did see your point.
By the way, do you remember who the reference was in that sociology course? That could be useful, and you might even use it again while writing the midterm paper, if you choose to write on this topic.
Actually, we are all very tired, but we only pretend to be still "surviving". Anyway, I will get in touch with my sociology professor, and learn more about this issue from a sociological perspective, and thereby definitely mention this in my midterm paper. Thank you very much for your useful suggestion!
YanıtlaSil:)
JackpotCity casino site | Lucky Club Live
YanıtlaSilJackpotCity casino site has more than 100 slot machines, including many more machines, such as video poker, roulette, video keno, luckyclub craps, video keno,